GoldenNewsNG
  • Home
  • News
  • Education
  • Business
  • Jobs
  • Daily Guides
  • About Us
  • Advertise with Us
  • Home
  • News
  • Education
  • Business
  • Jobs
  • Daily Guides
  • About Us
  • Advertise with Us
No Result
View All Result
Golden News
No Result
View All Result

PDP, Ebonyi Gov. Umahi, Deputy commence legal battle over defection

kunle kunle by kunle kunle
January 11, 2024
in Headline, Politics
Reading Time: 3 mins read
PDP, Ebonyi Gov. Umahi, Deputy commence legal battle over defection
11
SHARES
Advertisements

The Abuja division of the Federal High Court has fixed November 24 for definite hearing in the suit wherein the Peoples Democratic Party(PDP) is seeking the removal of Governor David Umahi of Ebonyi State and his deputy, Dr. Eric Kelechi Igwe on account of their defection from the party to the All Progressive Congress (APC).

But responding to the suit, Governor Umahi and have urged the court to dismiss it for being defective and a gross abuse of the court process.

READ ALSO

NELFUND Begins Disbursement of Upkeep Payments to Students with Updated Bank Accounts

FIRS to Launch Mandatory e-Invoicing System for Businesses with ₦5 Billion Turnover and Above

In an originating summons marked FHC/ABJ/CS/920/2021, the PDP has principally urged the court to make a declaration that by defecting from the party on which they were sponsored and elected as Governor and deputy governor of Ebonyi state, to the APC, a political party that did not win the election, they have resigned or deemed to have resigned from office.

The crux of the plaintiff’s case is that the defendants purportedly defected and relinquished their membership of the PDP on which platform they contested and won the governorship election, and by so doing are deemed to have lost the majority votes scored at the election and consequently should be ordered by the court to vacate their respective offices as Governor and deputy governor of Ebonyi state.

Challenging the competent of the suit through a counter affidavit filed by their counsel, Chukwuma-Machukwu Ume (SAN), Governor Umahi and his deputy drew the attention of the court to a similar suit marked FHC/ABJ/CS/729/2021, field earlier by the PDP and the Ebonyi state chairman of the party , Hon Fred Udeogu against the governor, the All Progressive Congress, the Independent National Electoral Commission and others on the same subject matter, reliefs and annexures attached as the instant case.

While praying the court to hold that the present action by the plaintiff is irritating, annoying and constituted a gross abuse of the court process, Ume submitted that his clients had already filed processes in defence of the suit FHC/ABJ/CS/729/2021 at the Abakaliki division of the court.

Still on the multiplicity of action, he referred the court to the judicial pronouncement of Justice Jummai Sankey of the Court of Appeal who stated thus: “Where two actions are instituted in court, the second one asking for a relief which may however be obtained in the first, the second action is, prima facie vexatious and an abuse of court process.”

He further cited the case of Lagos State V AG Federation and Ors (2014) LPELR-22701 (SC) where the Supreme Court held that “…Multiplicity of actsns which involve the same subject matter amount to abuse of court and the court has a duty to stop such abuse….”

Beyond the issue of abuse of court process, the defendants further challenged the mode of commencement of the suit by way of originating summons instead of a writ of summons, arguing that all the depositions in the plaintiff’s affidavit raised huge controversies and disputations that requires oral testimonies and cross-examinations to enable the court decipher the truth.

Citing a plethora of legal authorities including a Court of Appeal decision in Kehinde V ACN and others (2012), Ume submitted “the law is trite that contentious matters as in this instant suit are to be brought by way of writ of summons to enable party lead evidence and be cross-examined.

” The plaintiff’s orginating summons raised very controversial issues in which the defendants particularly 3rd and 4th defendants are disputing very strongly hence the need to call oral evidence to reconcile the conflict in the affidavit deposition and the documents attached therein.”

On same issue, the senior lawyer, citting the case law in Aromire and anor V Aromire and Ors (2019) LPELR-47704 (CA), submitted that the originating process is incurable defective, there being no signature of the Registrar of the court appearing on it, a condition precedent which affects the competence of the suit as well as the jurisdiction of the court.

In addition, Ume further submitted that his clients who are the current Executive Governor and deputy respectively, are sued in their personal capacities while still in office against the spirit of the constitutional provision of section 308, which clothed them with immunity against civil or criminal proceedings while in office.

On this point, Ume, a former Attorney General of Imo state emphasised in his written address, the fact that, “this section (308), applies to a person holding the office of the President or Vice-President, Governor or Deputy Governor; and the reference in this section to ” period of office” is a reference to the period during which the person holding such office is required to perform way functions of the office.”

📢 JOIN OUR WHATSAPP GROUP 📢 JOIN OUR TELEGRAM CHANNEL
Previous Post

Why Nigerian presidents are not loved by citizens until they’re dead – Fashola

Next Post

Afghanistan better than Nigeria under Buhari – Ortom blasts APC’s Philip Agbese

Related Posts

NELFUND Begins Disbursement of Upkeep Payments to Students with Updated Bank Accounts

NELFUND Begins Disbursement of Upkeep Payments to Students with Updated Bank Accounts

The Nigerian Education Loan Fund (NELFUND) has commenced the disbursement of upkeep allowances to students who have updated their bank...

Read moreDetails

FIRS to Launch Mandatory e-Invoicing System for Businesses with ₦5 Billion Turnover and Above

FIRS to Launch Mandatory e-Invoicing System for Businesses with ₦5 Billion Turnover and Above

The Federal Inland Revenue Service (FIRS) has announced that it will begin full implementation of the National Electronic Invoicing (e-Invoicing)...

Read moreDetails

Green Money Project 2025: How to Apply for FG Youth Agriculture Empowerment Programme

Green Money Projec

Are you a young Nigerian passionate about agriculture or looking to grow a business in agribusiness? The Federal Government has...

Read moreDetails

FG Orders Banks to Flag Accounts with Monthly Transactions Over ₦5 Million

FG Orders Banks to Flag Accounts with Monthly Transactions Over ₦5 Million

Federal Government has ordered all Nigerian banks to Flag Accounts with Monthly Transactions Over ₦5 million GoldenNewsNg reports that Nigerian...

Read moreDetails

JAMB Awards ₦710 Million to Six Tertiary Institutions for Outstanding Admission Practices

JAMB Awards ₦710 Million to Six Tertiary Institutions for Outstanding Admission Practices

JAMB has Awarded ₦710 Million to Six Tertiary Institutions for Outstanding Admission Practices GoldenNewsNg reports that the Joint Admissions and...

Read moreDetails

JAMB Cut Off Mark for Civil Engineering 2025/2026 in Nigerian Universities

JAMB Cut Off Mark for Civil Engineering

JAMB Cut Off Mark for Civil Engineering 2025/2026 in Nigerian Universities    If you’re planning to study Civil Engineering in...

Read moreDetails

NELFUND Begins Disbursement of Funds to Students in Saapade, MAPOLY, and LASUED

NELFUND Begins Disbursement of Upkeep Payments to Students with Updated Bank Accounts

NELFUND Begins Disbursement of Funds to Students in Saapade, MAPOLY, and LASUED GoldenNewsNg reports that the Federal Government has announced...

Read moreDetails

Official JAMB Cut Off Mark for Medicine and Surgery 2025/2026 In Nigerian Universities

Official JAMB Cut Off Mark for Medicine and Surgery 2025/2026 In Nigerian Universities

Official JAMB Cut Off mark for Medicine and Surgery 2025/2026   If you’re planning to study Medicine and Surgery in...

Read moreDetails

Official JAMB Cut Off Mark For Computer Science 2025/2026: Requirements And Admission Tips

JAMB Cut Off Mark For Computer Science

JAMB Cut Off Mark For Computer Science 2025: Requirements And Admission Tips   Are you aiming to study Computer Science...

Read moreDetails

Official JAMB Cut-Off Mark for Law in Nigerian Universities 2025

Official JAMB Cut-Off Mark for Law in Nigerian Universities 2025

JAMB Cut Off Mark For Law in Nigerian Universities 2025 Are you planning to study Law in a Nigerian university...

Read moreDetails
Load More
Next Post
Afghanistan better than Nigeria under Buhari – Ortom blasts APC’s Philip Agbese

Afghanistan better than Nigeria under Buhari – Ortom blasts APC’s Philip Agbese

SEARCH ADS

Latest Posts

NELFUND Begins Disbursement of Upkeep Payments to Students with Updated Bank Accounts
Education

NELFUND Begins Disbursement of Upkeep Payments to Students with Updated Bank Accounts

FIRS to Launch Mandatory e-Invoicing System for Businesses with ₦5 Billion Turnover and Above
business

FIRS to Launch Mandatory e-Invoicing System for Businesses with ₦5 Billion Turnover and Above

Green Money Projec
Headline

Green Money Project 2025: How to Apply for FG Youth Agriculture Empowerment Programme

FG Orders Banks to Flag Accounts with Monthly Transactions Over ₦5 Million
business

FG Orders Banks to Flag Accounts with Monthly Transactions Over ₦5 Million

JAMB Awards ₦710 Million to Six Tertiary Institutions for Outstanding Admission Practices
Education

JAMB Awards ₦710 Million to Six Tertiary Institutions for Outstanding Admission Practices

JAMB Cut Off Mark for Civil Engineering
Education

JAMB Cut Off Mark for Civil Engineering 2025/2026 in Nigerian Universities

NELFUND Begins Disbursement of Upkeep Payments to Students with Updated Bank Accounts
Education

NELFUND Begins Disbursement of Funds to Students in Saapade, MAPOLY, and LASUED

Official JAMB Cut Off Mark for Medicine and Surgery 2025/2026 In Nigerian Universities
Education

Official JAMB Cut Off Mark for Medicine and Surgery 2025/2026 In Nigerian Universities

JAMB Cut Off Mark For Computer Science
Daily Guides

Official JAMB Cut Off Mark For Computer Science 2025/2026: Requirements And Admission Tips

Official JAMB Cut-Off Mark for Law in Nigerian Universities 2025
Education

Official JAMB Cut-Off Mark for Law in Nigerian Universities 2025

© 2024 Golden News

  • About Us
  • Advertise with Us
  • Contact Us
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms And Conditions
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
  • Education
  • Business
  • Jobs
  • Daily Guides
  • About Us
  • Advertise with Us

© 2024 Golden News